india ποΈ Justice Datta: 'Judges Appoint Judges' is a myth
Supreme Court Justice Dipankar Datta stated that the phrase 'judges appoint judges' is a myth while hearing petitions on ECI appointment laws. He argued that the executive maintains substantial control over judicial appointments through selective implementation of Collegium recommendations. These points were raised while reviewing challenges to the 2023 law regarding the Chief Justice of India's removal from the ECI selection panel. Datta contended this process has weakened the judiciary relative to the executive branch. Nevertheless, he called the Collegium the most viable option for protecting judicial independence. ποΈ